That Prickly Tech Feeling

Tonight I spent an hour of my evening, as I often do, engaged in the Kinderchat conversation. Tonight we were discussing Google in the Classroom. It was a quieter chat for me. I didn’t engage as much as usual, and the evening chat left me with that itchy, prickly feeling like Leonard’s sweater from a Big Bang Theory episode. (The Itchy Brain Simulation) It took a bit of DMing a couple of friends to work out that prickly feeling.

There was a great deal of conversation at first about teachers using Google to collaborate with other teachers, parents and admin. I don’t have any problem with that. I love using Google with my tiegrad classmates and friends to communicate, share and do projects together, If I had parents who were willing to share their email address with the school, I would gladly start up a gmail account and Google calendar for the class.Some of the things that people were discussing were fabulous and noteworthy. My itchy sweater feeling wasn’t coming from there.

Then the discussion started to veer into how we as educators use Google and the Google Apps with the Kindergarten kids. Again, I think there are some great features within Google to use with the littles. We look for the provinces, states and towns where our twitter friends are on Google Maps. We search out places we want to travel to and places we are from on the map app. It is a great adventure for my kids to see the world spinning and to see how the other side of our planet is dark while we are sunny. So cool when you are 5 (or 41). We use Google images A LOT. Whenever we are not sure about some information or what something may look like, the cry is roused by small voices, “We should Google that!” and we often do. Google images has some amazing visuals for kids and I don’t want to stifle anyone’s passion for using Google in the kindergarten classroom.  But, when I hear of quizzes being made for and marked on Kinders in Google Sheets and the workbooks being made in Google Slides, it does makes me cringe. But again, the itchy sweater isn’t coming from there either.

Kinderchat talks a lot about issues close to our hearts. Two of my issues, play and the natural world, are topics we cover in the 8 week cycle of chat topics. My friends, Mardelle and Amy, really helped me to identify the itchy sweater tonight. When we talk about PLAY in the kindergarten classroom, there are many people who express why they aren’t able to play in the classroom: School regulations, testing, Common Core, and more. We try to provide advice, research and help for those who are advocating for play in their classes. During the NATURE chats, there are people expressing why they can’t take kids outside for play: there are no green spaces, school regulations, outdoor play is seen as unimportant and more. Again, support is provided and advice is given to those who need it.  But when the topic of technology comes up, there seems to be very little “I can’t” in the chat.  Tonight, a debate started over typing vs printing. Is typing important? Probably. Is it important to the fine motor muscles of a 4 or 5 year old? I would say no. Kinderchat co-creator Amy happened to have the research to show supporting her “teach printing” belief, and I am thankful for that. Somehow my “because my gut says so” defence seemed to lack something in the debate. But when I watch the finger muscle development of my students as they work with clay and plasticene, as they try to manipulate chopsticks this week, I know in my heart of heart, that they are not ready for typing in Kindergarten. Mardelle asked me a question that really defined my itchy sweater: “Why is tech such an easy sell when play, and being outside, is such a tough one?” The more research I read about anxiety and stress in young children, the more I wonder why we aren’t outside every single day. I am absolutely not against tech with the littles. It has it’s place in the school classroom and the natural classroom. But if it is simply becoming another workbook, worksheet, or flashcard tool, then we are not considering what is developmentally appropriate for the age. If we are willing to jump into technology with 2 feet, shouldn’t we be jumping into play and nature with our everything? I think you know where I stand. What do you think?

Tagged ,

9 thoughts on “That Prickly Tech Feeling

  1. Kierna says:

    Such a great post, Liane. And you are so right, schools can find funding for all kinds of fancy techy equipment but would rarely spend a fraction of that on outdoor clothing or resources.

  2. Michelle says:

    Interesting! I was part of the chat for a while before I had to leave (I’m @EarlyYearsIdeas) but to be honest, I found this one a rather tricky subject to get onboard with. In the same way as you – I am all for outdoor play and learning through nature and although I do believe that access to technology and learning some of the basics (like how to find information on google) are important skills – I really don’t use the internet or computer very much in my class at all.

    I think that might have been one of those “I can’t” voices if I had stuck around – but in reality it’s more of an “I wont”. Technology is wonderful in its way but nothing compares to the experiences that children have while exploring their natural world.

    I must admit – in my nursery, outdoor play is not a hard sell at all – the staff, parents and children all adore it and can see the benefits!

  3. hechternacht says:

    Reblogged this on heidi echternacht and commented:
    Fantastic post and points from Liane!

  4. hechternacht says:

    Homerun Liane!! Fantastic!

  5. faige says:

    Great post Liane. How do we best use our time at school day? Missed most of #kinderchat look at Google in the classroom. But I’d choose venturing into the world of play for kinders as well.

  6. Gail Poulin says:

    Great read. I found you via Heidi’s post. We don’t have a push at our school for using enough play and the outdoors. Tech is still a challenge as well especially with the younger kids and the limited tools for it. The CC standards are driving the bus and free thinking is almost discouraged. I think we have become a society of indoor people and now it requires a push to get folks outdoors for any learning. I watched this funny video about it on FB which makes the point as well.

  7. keeneelou says:

    Sometimes I want to rip that itchy sweater off and throw it across the room! You have said what I feel in a very eloquent and non-itchy way. Thank you!

  8. keeneelou says:

    Oh, and never worry about your gut feeling. It’s totally legit. 😉

  9. Jane Rees says:

    Well said. From my experiences, communicating about the benefits and need for play in all children seems unnecessary, but is what is needed. Parents and educators need to know the value in these creative and calming activities when provided to children.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

roads bel travelled

Exploring open roads without breaking the bank

mardelle sauerborn

Thinking out loud.

heidi echternacht

the personal and professional :: photography, posts, poetry, practice

My Kindergarten Bubble

My life as a kindergarten teacher

Geek My Gadget

Scouring the web for the latest geekware so you don't have to!

Pasir Ridge Intercultural School

We bring the world to our classrooms.


Just another site


Blogging about everything sweet and sticky...

STaRT Technology Learning Network

Learning Together Through Collaborative Inquiry

Just another site

Oldfield's Wanderings

Objects in blog are closer than they appear

Catching Readers Before They Fall

Supporting Readers Who Struggle, K-4

Searching for Sunshine

@MauiMickey's Thoughts on Teaching, Family, Travel, Food & Everything Else

Not In A Blue Box

My Journey Documented Here

%d bloggers like this: